Look at existing types of aquaponics systems
There are many kinds of aquaponics systems. They mostly differ by the arrangement of their elements, type of tanks, used technologies and size. Here you’ll find their overview.
The most common kinds of fish in aquaponics
The most bred kind of fish in aquaponics is the Nile Tilapia (Oreochromis Niloticus). The Tilapia requires warmer water, but offers good meat, endurance and fast growth. In the USA it belongs into the most favorite freshwater fish and therefore it’s breeding and selling there is relatively easy. Others, mostly in Australia bred fish are various percinae fish (breeding of Nile Tilapia is banned in Australia). Rainbow Trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) is the other possible choice for aquaponics breeding. This kind is also perspective for Europe conditions because it is popular consuming fish there, but it requires high quality water. Another fish that can be bred in aquaponic systems is grass carp or pangasius, eventually even carp. Koi and decorative Crucians are the most common bred fish that aren’t used to consumption. They are mostly used in demonstrative systems or in decorative aquaponic ponds.
The most commonly grown plants in aquaponics
The oldest and still grown plant is Watercress, Nasturtium officinale. It is an undemanding water plan with little spicy taste, which is used in salads and is popular in France. Nowadays the most grown plants are mostly various kinds of salads and leaf vegetable, which grows very well on floating rafts. Other vegetables are tomatoes, paprika or chili peppers. Some growers are experimenting with root vegetable. Many kinds of herbs are also very favored, for example basil. From fruits, which is also very popular in aquaponics, strawberries are the most popular. These are usually grown in NFT systems or vertical towers (read below).
An aquaponics systems can be divided by their size to:
Nowadays you can buy commercially available aquaponic „mini systems“ from producers from Australia and USA. These assemblies can be an interesting addition to the kitchen, however their functionality is problematic. Small volume of water is prone to swings in a quality and these small aquaponics have to be cleaned as often as common aquariums. Plants in them will suffer from lack of some nutrients and light stress from uneven lighting.
Hobby and garden systems
These little to medium sizes of the systems are usually placed in private properties of individuals – handy man, who run aquaponics as a hobby. The most used growing substrate is gravel, ceramsite, lava gravel or eventually even floating rafts. In hobby aquaponics earthworms are often added into substrate to help with decomposing organic remains and speed up mineralization. In larger hobby system we can encounter with NFT (read below) and separation of solid waste.
Big commercial systems
Most of existing aquaponic systems designated for selling fish and vegetables belong here. Usually it consists of one or several systems in one greenhouse with growing area of tens to hundreds quarter meters. Growing plants on rafts is by far the most popular method. On the northeast of USA the type with long multilevel tanks from wood and EPDM foil by the design of Will Allen form Milwaukee is very frequent.
Big commercial systems
Into the big commercial systems comes systems with area over thousand square meters.
Another way to divide aquaponics systems is by used technology and way of breeding fish:
Growing in periodically flooded tanks filled with substrate.
It is the most common type of growing used in a small aquaponic systems. It is also called Flood & Drain. The tank is equipped with „siphon“, which after filling automatically drives water away from growing tank further into the system. This way the periodically flooded substrate (ceramsite, gravel) gives the roots of plants ideal environment rich with both nutrients and oxygen. Tanks filled with substrate are also put before growing tanks with rafts as a filter against solid particles and bio filter, where the nitrification happens.
Rafts are mostly represented by polystyrene plates, with holes for baskets or mineral wool with plant seedlings. Plans thus flow on the surface of growing tank that has shape of a shallow pool. Roots of plants then are in water column. Steady water flow or placement of air stones is required for sufficient oxygen and nutrient distribution. Advantage of this system is very easy manipulation with singular polystyrene plates, thus so with plants that are comfortably harvested.
NFT means Nutrient Film Technique. This way of growing is often used in hydroponics and it is a system of pipes with holes for individual plants. Very shallow water flows through the system. Roots of plants get nutrients from film of water and oxygen from the air.
This modified variant of NFT allows growing big amount of flowers in a small place. Water flows through the tower thanks to gravity and distributes nutrients to plants planted in special foamed matter. This kind of growing is sold as ZipGrow towers by Dr. Nate Storey at the Bright Agrotech. This method requires very good filtration of solid sludge that could clog the water distribution and even the vertical tower itself.
This method is ultimate method of hydroponic growing that can be used also in the aquaponics. Roots of plants are sprayed with drops of nutrient solution from special nozzles. This method maximizes roots oxygen supply, which thanks to that absorb nutrients better and thanks to that vegetables grow a lot faster. On the other hand it is very technically challenging and it requires very good filtration system that gets rid of the entire solid waste.
Aquariums are very aesthetic and design solutions for aquaponics in interiors. Because of size limitations they are only used in the small systems. Their advantage is the ability to watch bred fish, which are then often only decorative. Their biggest problem is ensuring good water flow, filtration of sludge and reducing algae growth so that it is always pretty to look at.
It is the most popular type of tanks used for breeding fish and growing plants. IBC are plastic containers for liquids or beverages with outer reinforcing metal cage. These containers are used for transporting various liquids and are very popular by gardeners, who are using them to collect rain water.
Their shape and capacity (1000 liters) makes them ideal for small or modular aquaponic systems and small private breeders often use them to breed fish. Another advantage is presence of the dump valve at the bottom of the tank.
Wood tanks in the multilevel system of Will Allen
This, now almost historical, probably originates from Will Allen from Milwaukee. Tanks are assembled from (larch) planks to fit area of a greenhouse and are covered from the inside with EPDM rubber. Tank for fish is in the bottom part and growing tanks are placed in several levels above them. Water is pumped to the topmost level and then it flows down through each „level“ back to the fish. Advantage of this is significant space savings and large growing area. Disadvantage of this system is mostly bad sludge management, which is filtrated only by gravel substrate. The gravel has to be „washed“ from time to time. Rectangular shape of the fish tank also limits ideal flow of water, which is worse than in a circular tank.
Circular tanks, hatcheries or pools
This is the best type of tank that is little less space saving, however it offers large volumes of water for fish breeding (thousands of liters) and very good water flowing that improves whole aquaponics cycle. Water is usually let in to the tank in one way and this creates a little whirl. This is good for healthy movement of the fish and most importantly concentrates solid part of fish waste in the center of tank. From there the sludge can be moved very fast to the setting or filtration tank. Because of that water in these systems is often very clean. Fish excrements aren’t grinded by airing and don’t set in the corners of tank, but are moved whole further into the system, where they can be processed. The volume of subtle particles, that slowly clog the system, is minimal.
Interesting way to use decorative garden ponds or tanks is linking them with hydroponic bed. However this system is only suited for hot areas, where it is able to grow under the sky for big part of a year (south of the USA, Australia). Hydroponic bed often replaces expensive filtration device. These aquaponic systems are very robust, because they are managed by the nature.
Biology and chemistry: Key basics of aquaponics
Aquaponics couldn’t work without natural processes. Problematic of biology and chemistry in aquaponics systems is very extensive and complicated. Look at basic mechanisms of the most important processes, whose right adjustment and control is indispensable for good working aquaponics system.
Good knowledge of biological and chemical processes is the key of successful aquaponics growing. However that requires large volume of knowledge from the grower or serving staff of the farm that can be compared to professional personnel of large fish or hydroponics farm. Operating an aquaponics farm means putting those two professions together. This fact is the biggest peril of the whole aquaponics and its development.
There are two most important processes in aquaponics and we have to mention them. The first one is nitrification, which is done by special nitrification bacteria. It is a biological process of changing ammonia (NH4+) that fish release from their gills and its oxidization to nitrite (NO2-) a then to nitrate (NO3-), which can be absorbed by plants. Ammonia and nitrite is very toxic for the fish even in small doses and plats have hard time using them, meanwhile nitrate is ideal fertilizer and fish can tolerate quite large concentration of it. Nitrification goes on best in the dark with good oxygen supply, at the same time the nitrification bacteria are vulnerable to fast changes of pH and doesn’t work right in an unstable system. If lack of oxygen comes up for any reason then this process turns into denitrification. Bacteria start using nitrite as a source of oxygen and pure nitrogen begins to escape from the system and spreads out.
Nitrification bacteria aren’t pathogenic for a human. They can get to a new aquaponics system either spontaneously or put there artificially. If they have the right conditions then they’ll fastly populate the new environment and within moments the nitrification process gets started.
The other important process is mineralization. This is done by large scale of bacteria and other microorganisms that decompose sludge into simple compounds that are soluble in water and later are be used by the plants. This process is also aerobic; it requires enough oxygen for its running. In aquaponics systems the solid waste is usually separated in a special tank and intensively aired. Created solution that is rich with nutrients is then returned back into the system and is used by plants for their growth. This was it is possible to change the whole sludge info fertilizer for plants increasing efficiency of the aquaponics system. With lack of oxygen in the water, this process of mineralization turns into fermentation. This is undesirable in an aquaponics system, because it can strongly change chemical properties of the water, mainly its pH.
For good working of microbiological processes in an aquaponics system it is required to establish lots of areas for bacterial colonization. Nitrification bacteria like stable and dark environment. So an ideal place for them is in the filtration substrate. In the most cases it is gravel, ceramsite, lava gravel (on Hawaii), zeolite or special filtration matter and filling like in the aquarium filters. These materials have lots of small surfaces, where can the nitrification bacteria live. Amount of material needed depends mostly on its porosity, total volume of water in the system and amount of bred fish. In case of small garden aquaponics with gravel or ceramsite Australian growers recommend 1:1 volume of the filtration medium to volume of fish tank. In small aquaponics the required size of bio filter is usually exceeded, which raises the stability of the small system. In big aquaponics you have to thoroughly evaluate size and type of bio filter, eventually even their suitable combination.
Oxygen is the most important substance in the whole aquaponics, because it enables processes of changing waste into nutrients and is also used by fish and roots of plats to breathe. With oxygen in aquaponics the more the better applies. Oxygen naturally passes from air to water, where this is influenced mostly by temperature (warmer water can take less oxygen than the cold one) and area of surface between air and water. It is hard to check concentration of oxygen without special lab equipment, that’s why there are many ways in aquaponics to keep its levels in water as high as possible. The most common one, but not always best, is using air stones in fish tanks. Although it is the most efficient way of getting oxygen into water its disadvantage is big mixing of water and therefore pulverization of fish excrements into very small particles. Those are then faster clogging the bio filter and create sediments in aquaponics distributing pipes. Subtle parts of sludge settle down on biofilm made of stringy bacteria and can cause even total clogging of pipes. Better way of placing air stones are tanks with rafts or settling tank, from where is the collected water pumped back to fish tank. In well-designed systems, which have good hydrodynamics, airing usually isn’t needed, because there aren’t any blind spots in a tank, where the water would stay for a long time and frequent contact of water with outside air is ensured.
Water temperature affects speed of biological processes in a system. Nitrification bacteria work best in temperature between 25 and 28°C. With decreasing temperature their activity declines and at 4 °C it stops. If an aquaponics system freezes, nitrification bacteria will start to die. After unfreezing and reinitiating the system, their numbers will soon go back to the original.
Water temperature in an aquaponics system is mostly regulated for the needs of bred fish. They are prone to changing temperatures and can even die to heat shock if it changes too fast. This is true in case of releasing new fish into the tank and their acclimatization. Most bred fish in aquaponics the Nile Perch has quite high temperature requirements (26-28°C) and her breeding is hardly sustainable in temperatures under 20°C. This puts a big burden on breeder to heat the water, therefore rising running costs. Advantage of higher water temperature is its ability to heat an aquaponics greenhouse during winter months, reducing the need to heat the air itself (but it doesn’t disappear, more so if the system has to produce vegetables like salads or tomatoes even in winter months).
Even grown plans, their roots respectively, are affected by water temperature. The optimal temperature for roots of many vegetables to grow properly is a bit lower (about 18-24°C), than for some kinds of fish (Nile Tilapia). It doesn’t mean that plants will not grow in warm water, but rate of their growth slows down.
PH values are the most important parameter after the temperature. Checking pH is very easy, with many available tests in paper or solution type. Breeder’s goal is to ensure the most stable pH in an aquaponics environment, because nitrification and even availability of trace elements for roots of plants and satisfaction of fish depends on its value. Appropriate pH can differ from system to system. It is said that the most ideal interval is 6,5 – 7,5. The very best pH value should be 6,8, nevertheless it isn’t easy and desirable to keep it at that point. Every system can have slightly different value. The widest value that shouldn’t be crossed in an aquaponics system is 6,0-8,0.
Refilling of trace elements
Fish organism requires less iron, potassium, calcium or manganese than plants to grow. Therefore ratio of those elements in fish feed is lower (to nitrogen) than would be ideal for plants. This often times causes deficit of mostly iron and calcium in aquaponics solution and plats can suffer from lacking them. That can manifest by bad growth or by various defects of leaves like faded color, spots or withered parts. The most supplied element in aquaponics is iron, its lack manifests by bright spots on leaves of plants.
Elements are supplied in form of powder or solution. Those can be bought in chemically pure form. However their consumption in an aquaponics system is very small and they don’t represent sizable financial unit. An aquaponics can be operated even without supplying those elements; however that requires bigger ratio of fish to plants so that the small amount of those elements in fish feed would be delivered in surplus. This also requires integrating of denitrification part into the aquaponics cycle, where the excess nitrogen is turned into gas and released.
Plants unlike fish require large volume of light for their growth. Ensuring sufficient lighting of grown plants is the basic assumption for successful growing. This could be a problem in an interior aquaponics system that has lack of natural lighting and requires artificial lighting. Illumination of grown plants that are very light demanding (salads, paprika, tomatoes), is required to keep reasonable production during winter month on our latitude. Alternative is to grow less light and heat demanding plants. Those are for example spinach, broccoli or kale. Appropriate lighting is the same as the one used in hydroponics. The choice of right variant of lighting source is decided by financial resources and total form of the aquaponics system.
In greenhouse systems the best type is sodium-vapor lamps, which have sufficient lighting power and can illuminate sizeable area. However they make a lot of heat and have to be kept at distance from plants. Fop smaller interior placed systems fluorescent lights are better choice, or even LED panels, which are nowadays still more expensive, but provide specific part of light spectrum for photosynthesis and have much longer longevity than fluorescent lights. Those have to be replaced about every 12 months because their power wanes with time.
Right ratio of fish and plants
Ratio of bred fish and grown plans is another big topic of talks in aquaponics, which is very important and the right setting is required to keep this „ecosystem“ running. In reality this is about ratio of given feed to amount of grown plants, because we are trying to reach a balanced movement of nutrients from fish to plants.
On many different forums you can read various approaches how to count the best ratio between fish and plant, nevertheless every guide isn’t based on real knowledge of operating an aquaponics system. Basically it is one-way motion of nutrients that change inside the system, from complex organic substances (fish feed) to simple elements dissolved in watery slope, which can be consumed by plants (for example nitrates). If we want to design a system with the right ratios, we have to think in this plane of nutrients movement from one form to the other, from fish to plants. Dr. Wilson Lennard from Australia is working with approx. 16 g of fish feed on 1 square meter of growing area daily in his aquaponics systems. He defines this area as 30 plants (salad) in bed of floating rafts. This ratio means that 30 pcs of salad grown in 1 square meter are able to absorb nitrogen contained in 16 g of fish feed daily. However this ratio is only tentative for every other aquaponics system other than the one that it was counted for (Lennard uses whole mineralization of excrements). Every single one aquaponics system has a different dynamic of fish feed transformation into available nutrients for plants. Among the factors that affect this ratio belongs: type of fish feed and its nutrient content, design of the system, volume of water, rate of nitrification and mineralization, kinds of bred fish and efficiency of their digestion, water temperature and amount of dissolved oxygen. Last but not least also type of fish feed and its nutrient content. Ratio of feed dosage to growing area has to be counted for every system individually.
Let’s make an example of counting the right ratio of feed dosage to growing area. If we take the data from Lennard’s system, which uses the whole mineralization of excrements, therefore changes 100% of feed to available nutrients, every square meter of growing area will require minimally 16 g of feed. In the case of having growing area of 10 square meters, we’ll have to supply 160g of feed into system every day. Imagine we breed a carp that has daily feed dosage of 2-3% of his weight in temperature around 22 ° C. In lower temperatures will his metabolism slow down and he’ll consume less feed.
160 g therefore represents daily feed dosage for approximately 5,5 kg of carps. In a tank of 1000l volume we would get fish density of 5,5 kg/m3.
As is obvious from above text the problematic of nutrient cycle in an aquaponics system is very complex. Understanding and using it right is the most essential part to reach success in aquaponics growing, because it affects every other aspect of aquaponics.
What are pros and cons of an aquaponics system?
Aquaponics growing of plants and breeding fish has many advantages but also some disadvantages. Are you interested what positives an aquaponics farm brings and which negatives to look out for? We have made detailed comparison for you.
Advantages of aquaponics systems
Advantages of an aquaponics system against ordinary growing in soil medium are (according to external sources):
- More than 90 % less water consumption during plants growing than growing in a soil medium.
- 4-10x larger production of plants on area unit (different growers show different results).
- It is possible to reach total absence of artificial fertilizers (in many cases it is required to supply the system with some microelements).
- Operation is environment friendly (aquaponics doesn’t burden nearby surface waters with waste from aquaculture).
- American growers say that they need about half time to harvest vegetables (primarily thanks to larger plants production to area and time unit).
- Less pest occurrence, especially of those that are bound to soil.
- Usable in every climate zone. The system is very adaptable.
- Highly modular system that allows many different configuration and „turnkey“ building.
- System is suited for whole year growing of plants and breeding fish, even in areas where there is a lack of water or appropriate soil.
- System works the best in environment of controlled greenhouses, where growing is possible during whole year without regard for climate zones.
- The big heat capacity of water can partly heat a greenhouse during winter months, where is it possible to grow other than only aquaponics plants.
- Growing and selling products from aquaponics sounds like interesting investment and can bring the grower into spotlight with his customers and even attract new ones.
Disadvantages of aquaponics systems
- The need of electric energy and having a backup generator for water pump and airing (if present).
- Building and successfully running an aquaponics requires certain „know-how“ and relatively big initial investment.
- In some cases it is needed to supply some nutrients for a healthy plants growth (mostly iron – Fe and calcium – Ca, eventually potassium – K). Quality of plants nutrition is based on quality of fish feed.
- The need for additional heating of the greenhouse in winter in colder climate zones.
What is the future of aquaponics?
For many years was the aquaponics only domain of enthusiasts in some English speaking countries. Nowadays there are appearing many new half commercial or commercial projects that move the aquaponics growing to higher level. Number of farms and organizations that have aquaponics as one of many activities is rising.
Some of the obstacles of extension of aquaponics growing between farmers are high initial costs, big volume of required knowledge and know-how. Even though aquaponics firstly started gaining popularity in north American environment, which is very different from the European one (market, agriculture conditions, land costs), the number of subjects dealing in aquaponics is also rising in Europe.
An issue is relative difficulty of operating an aquaponic system and large requirement of knowledge about its functionality. This could be solved in the future by developing intelligent sensors and applications that would give full and understandable information to the user and helped with controlling and running the whole system.
One possible application of aquaponics is a city vertical farm that could use many linked production systems and renewable power sources.
If the issues of an aquaponics are able to be solved in near future, we can expect its expansion as a new source of producing certain foodstuffs. But for that there will be one required the most important thing, stable demand for ecological, local and fresh foodstuffs. Exactly what an aquaponics can offer.
Aquaponics on Mars
The aquaponics is talked about as a technology that will be used in conquering the space, because it is highly effective in space, water and material requirement. Aquaponics could be the first technology that would produce animal proteins as fish meat to future colonists; however, it will not happen in the first phases of Red planet’s colonization. First settler will have to be strictly vegetarian and mostly use highly effective hydroponics growing.
Frequently asked questions about aquaponics
What conditions do you need to successfully run an aquaponics? What kinds of vegetables can you grow on an aquaponics farm? Does fish suffer in a tank? Read answers to the most asked question about aquaponics.
Does aquaponics work as a closed system that produces vegetables and fish for free?
Aquaponics isn’t a Perpetuum mobile, but is called a Close-loop System. From technological look it is a recirculating system of intense fish breeding in artificial tanks and with pumping water into hydroponics part, where plants take nutrients for their growth, water is biologically and mechanically cleaned and goes back to fish tank. Unlike in normal fish breeding the polluted water isn’t released into environment, but circulates in the system forever and is used as a nutrient solution for the plants. Fish excrements then serve as a fertilizer for grown vegetables. So, we have to add fish feed into the system at least. And in some cases, even trace element, which aren’t present in enough volume to allow plans to grow properly. Another assumption is enough of lighting and heat for growing plants. Even then it is almost closed (eco)system that works on the same principle as ponds, but is artificially controlled. More about that here.
Is it possible to run successful aquaponic system in European conditions?
The biggest problems for commercial aquaponics in European conditions would be climate and sales on the market. Cold climate raises costs for heating, lighting, used materials and technologies. However, the rule is bigger the farm, lesser the costs for produced kilogram.
Does any big commercial aquaponics growing projects exist in foreign countries?
They do, countries like the USA or Australia have commercial aquaponics farms. This way farmers supply fresh fish meat and vegetables to local farmers markets or to system of Community supported agriculture. Most of these farms were created only recently. An aquaponics growing for commercial purposes is the question of the last few years.
Can anyone run an aquaponics?
For long-term and successful running of an aquaponics you have to have much knowledge about breeding fish, chemical processes and needs of plants. But even inexperienced growers can have partial success in the beginning, however if the system gets „of the rails“ they are often helpless and may not find cause of the problem. In that case loss of fish and plants can get very big.
What kind of fish and plants are the best for an aquaponics?
Nile Perch (Oreochromis Niloticus) is the most commonly bred fish. Other common kinds are perch and decorative fish for example Koi and Crucian. The most commonly grown are many kinds of leaf vegetables, tomatoes and paprika. Older aquaponics systems used to grow for instance water loving and undemanding Watercress (Nasturtium Officinale). Various kinds of herbs are also favored, mostly Ocimum. From fruit strawberries surely win. Curiosities might be for example pineapple or banana tree. Some growers are trying root vegetables, although it doesn’t prosper very much in periodically flooded substrates.
Does fish suffer in an artificial tank?
The most bred fish in an aquaponics are naturally forming flocks, so higher number in a tank is ideal for them. Circular or oval tanks aren’t stressful to fish; on the contrary they allow good water flow, which helps with healthy activity and supply of oxygen and fresh water. It is responsibility of every breeder to provide good conditions for his fish, including right temperature and pH of water and enough oxygen and food.
Is it possible to build and operate an aquaponics based on the informations available online? (youtube, internet forums etc.)
You can find many videos, advices and guides about aquaponics on the internet. But certain care has to be taken with their acceptance, because not everything that looks very effectively on the internet, works on reality. Many aquaponics enthusiasts are publishing their advices, although they have none long-term experience. Therefore it is good to take information from people, who spent some time in aquaponics and have made several successful projects.
Is there interest for this type of agriculture in the Europe?
There is a small one, but it is slowly rising. The biggest obstacle of aquaponics is unknowingness and novelty of this agricultural type.
It is possible to support yours family with an aquaponics in case of society breakdown?
That would be very hard. An aquaponics can produce fish meat, vegetables and some kinds of fruit. That of course doesn’t cover every nutrition and culinary needs of a human. Garden aquaponics systems mostly serve as an interesting element, which can complement family’s consumption off fresh foodstuffs. If you want to live independent of the society and have so called food self-sufficiency, then the best strategy would be to have a family farm in countryside, where an aquaponics farm could produce large volumes of vegetables and fish food for whole year. In case of any crisis it would be faster and less difficult to grow vegetables classically in soil than to design and build and aquaponics systems. These situations really happened during the First and Second World Wars, when city parks in the USA and Europe were plowed and created so called Victory or War Gardens. aquaponics could be used within some strategy towards higher diverse of food supplies in regions and local production of fresh foodstuffs in cities.
Yes, you are reading that right, in 2017 the decision was made and THORILEX is expanding.
We have noticed a demand from abroad in past and we weren’t targeting on other markets.
Interest from other markets hasn’t left us calm, so in 2017 we made the decision. Our vision doesn’t end in the Czechia so this was essential step to support our growth.